[ClusterLabs] Cluster Lab Query: Pacemaker 3.0.3 controld SIGSEGV on repeated resource start-failure → cluster shutdown (not seen on 2.1.6)

Chris Lumens clumens at redhat.com
Wed Nov 4 20:44:28 UTC 2026


> To compare behavior, we intentionally kept one resource (an OCF agent 
> whose start consistently fails) in a permanent start-failure state.

Can you show me the OCF agent and its configuration in the CIB so I can 
try to reproduce this?  Once I can, I'll dig into your bug report more 
thoroughly.  Thanks for the detail.

>   * A single resource that repeatedly fails 'start' drives Pacemaker
>     into a continuous stop -> start -> stop recovery loop (roughly every
>     30s in our setup).
>   * After *~2 days / ~2300 failed start attempts*, pacemaker-controld
>     crashed with signal 11 (SIGSEGV), and because the controld respawn
>     budget was exhausted, pacemakerd  declared a fatal failure and shut
>     the whole stack down, and it stays down.

Hopefully we can figure this out so no one ever runs into a segfault 
after two days, but I hate the idea of segfaults lurking in the code 
anywhere.  Can you show me a backtrace of that as well so we can take a 
look?

>  1. Is this a known issue / already fixed after 3.0.3 in the controller
>     or IPC (libcrmcommon mainloop_gio / event-notification) code?

No, I don't think this has been encountered before.  It definitely 
hasn't been fixed.

>  2. Is there a recommended configuration workaround to avoid the fatal
>     path while a fix is pending (e.g. tuning around resource failure
>     handling)?

You could try changing the on-fail setting for the start action of the 
resource to be "stop" instead of "restart".  There's likely some 
timeouts and thresholds you could configure as well, but I am not 
familiar with all the details.  You'd need to check "Pacemaker 
Explained" or "Pacemaker Adimistration" for more details.

Is there any chance you've tried on other releases as well?  There's a 
*ton* of differences between 2.1.6 and 3.0.3:

$ git diff --stat Pacemaker-2.1.6..Pacemaker-3.0.3
...
  3636 files changed, 222158 insertions(+), 149509 deletions(-)

In particular, if you tried any other 3.0.x releases, that would be 
especially helpful to know.

- Chris



More information about the Users mailing list